The Knox Student

First Place in Division | 2012 General Excellence | Illinois College Press Association
Advanced
  • News
    • Campus
    • Community
    • National
    • International
  • Mosaic
    • Arts & Culture
    • Reviews
  • Discourse
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Letters
  • Sports
    • The Prairie Fire
    • National
  • Blog
  • Media
  • Follow us on Google+
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Like us on Facebook
  • Follow us via RSS

Read? Watch? Why not both?

Bridging text and television

By Renni Johnson

May 2, 2012

Tweet

In the last decade audiences have seen the best-selling popular books become film. From children’s and young adult novels such as “Harry Potter,” “Twilight,” “Eragon” and “Percy Jackson” to adult series including “The Lord of the Rings,” “Sookie Stackhouse” (HBO’s “True Blood”) and the advent of HBO’s “Game of Thrones” based on “The Song of Ice and Fire” series by George R. R. Martin, our favorite reading material is optimal blockbuster material. As a marketing strategy, producers can be assured that a majority of the readership can be turned into viewing audiences.

With every release, however, come the bevy of complaints and compunctions over the differences between our beloved books and their reproductions. Deviations and failed expectations seem unavoidable, what with the difficulty in turning 300-some pages of words into a two-hour visual experience, not to mention the impossibility of finding an actor who lives up to the perfect Edward Cullen in our heads. This should come as no surprise to anybody — Robert Pattinson doesn’t cut it. However, “Game of Thrones” changes the game.

Released in the spring of 2011, the first season of “Game of Thrones” encapsulated the first book of George R. R. Martin’s series. The pilot’s opening is coherent with the prologue. The end scene of the season finale in which Daenerys hatches her dragons is the final chapter of the book. Anyone else who’s read the books and seen the television series will note that there are significant disparities, but the divergences are opportunistic.

Martin’s books are written from the third-person free-indirect point of view of his main characters. He takes pages to explain familial, political and cultural histories and nuances. The worldly details and close proximity to favorite characters are lost in media translation, but in exchange readers are shown the costumes, get to hear their voices, and are given scenes with secondary characters otherwise “off-stage” in the books.

Ask a reader if King Renly is gay, and they might tell you they are not sure, but ask the viewer and they will say that is obvious. If you’re reading and watching Martin’s series you get the best of both forms, plus a richer, fuller experience.

Season two of “Game of Thrones,” covering book two, “A Clash of Kings,” was released on April 1 of this year — this past Sunday was episode five — and Martin’s fifth book in the series, “A Dance with Dragons,” was published last summer (about the same time as HBO’s first season ended, wouldn’t you know.)

Though the differences in the book and the show have gotten more significant, including a name change, the show continues to be a suspenseful, sensual fantasy drama worth the expense to feast your eyes on. Paired with the books, an absorbing, textured read in and of themselves, the “Game of Thrones” experience is a triumph of television drama and literature. The partnership is an innovation for media and marketing that will change the way people read and watch their favorite stories.

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

TKS editors reserve the right to remove any comments that are off-topic or contain hate speech or personal attacks.

  • Campus and Community Events

    May 25 Sat
    8:30 pm Union Board presents: Pitch Perfect @ South lawn of Old Main (rain location: Kresge Recital Hall)
    Union Board presents: Pitch Perfect @ South lawn of Old Main (rain location: Kresge Recital Hall)
    May 25 @ 8:30 pm – 10:30 pm
    Union Board is sponsoring a showing of “Pitch Perfect” on the lawn. Bring your own blankets.
    May 26 Sun
    6:30 pm Mary Harlan piano studio recital @ Kresge Recital Hall
    Mary Harlan piano studio recital @ Kresge Recital Hall
    May 26 @ 6:30 pm – 7:30 pm
    The students of Mary Harlan present a piano studio recital.
    May 27 Mon
    12:00 pm Sixth Semi-Annual Conference on Alternatives to Consumerism @ Seymour Gallery
    Sixth Semi-Annual Conference on … @ Seymour Gallery
    May 27 @ 12:00 pm – 1:00 pm
    Students in the Alternatives to Consumerism course will be making poster presentations about a variety of ways to live happier, more sustainable lives than what [...]

    View Calendar

  • Popular Stories

    • Trees cut down outside of SMC
    • Terpsichore explores its ‘Scope’
    • The State of Knox Athletics | Part 2: Changing perspectives
    • New Galesburg shop digs up vintage, modern
    • Senate election winners look forward
  • Related Stories

    • A return to pleasure reading
    • ‘Crash by Sunny Bow Mar Lake’ barrels into Studio Theatre
    • New Plays sings a ‘Summer Song’
    • Adaptation falls short of Fitzgerald’s original
    • ‘Gatsby’ soundtrack good, but not ‘Great’
  • Featured Poll

    Was the administration's response to this year's mud pit reasonable?

  • About
  • Staff
  • Awards
  • FAQs
  • Ethics statement
  • Contact Us
  • Place an ad
  • Suggest a story
  • Submit an event
  • Subscribe
  • Site
  • Special topics
  • Advanced search
  • The Knox Student
  • (309) 341-7418
  • tks@knox.edu
  • Knox College K-240
    2 E. South St.
    Galesburg, IL 61401-4999

Copyright © 2013 The Knox Student. All content on theknoxstudent.com is the property of The Knox Student unless otherwise noted, and it may not be reproduced or published without express permission from said content's creator(s) and the editor-in-chief. Opinions expressed in the print and/or online editions of The Knox Student are not necessarily those of Knox College or of its faculty, administration or student body.