Columns / Discourse / January 23, 2013

Debating columnists: A.I.G. potential lawsuit

Some like to behave like children. You give a kid a cookie, and they are probably going to ask for more (at least I did). But sometimes, “grown ups” tend to act like children. They don’t seem to want to mature. And sometimes, it’s people like this that direct important financial institutions.

Say hello to A.I.G. They are acting like children, but it didn’t happen overnight.

The 2008 crisis was a disaster. It dragged Wall Street to the ground and looked like there was no recovery in sight. The Bush Administration stepped in and decided that it would be beneficial to bail out major Wall Street institutions like A.I.G. or else the economy would ultimately collapse.

A.I.G. is now mostly publicly owned. About 77 percent of A.I.G.’s assets belong to the government and come up to $186 billion. A.I.G. only owns about $14.9 billion of its shares.

It’s pathetic that such a powerful institution still hasn’t paid back its bailout money. Companies like these should not be part of the private sector in the first place. If A.I.G. couldn’t come up with the money in the last four years since the bailout, then it doesn’t deserve more money from the government and should be completely privatized.

The problem is that A.I.G. is not alone. Fannie and Freddie are other major financial institution that paid little of the money back. They took $187.5 billion and paid back $50.4 billion. Fannie and Freddie should be privatized and be left alone to fend off the market like every other normal company.

The most embarrassing part isn’t their incompetence or lack of profit, it’s their arrogance. A.I.G. took the money from taxpayers and now they have the audacity to consider a lawsuit against the government.

Maurice R. Greenberg, A.I.G.’s former chief executive, encouraged his shareholders to file a lawsuit against the federal government for preventing billions of dollars of profit from the company because of its state-owned status.

With all due respect to Mr. Greenberg, his company should’ve lost everything in the first place. If a company fails, then it fails. There is no reason why the government should nationalize a company that can’t make a profit. A free market system makes some businesses successful and bankrupts others. Those that go bankrupt are out of touch with the economy and don’t innovate to stay afloat.

Pan Am was one of them. It was the biggest airline in the U.S. and went bankrupt in 1991. The result wasn’t turmoil in the airline industry but a refreshing rise to new airlines. The deregulation of the 1980s brought more competition in the industry and it broke the all too powerful monopoly title that Pan Am held. The 1980s created new routes and lowered airfares.

It’s okay to fail. That’s why we have a free market system. Bailouts are not a good idea and A.I.G. made it pretty clear last week. Once they get something for free, they’re going to ask for more and get arrogant about it as well.

There should be no favoritism in the markets. There should be no subsidies — yes that includes subsidies for oil companies, projects of nationalization and/or bailouts. The bottom line is, greed shouldn’t be subsidized. The government should stay out of the business of propping up corporations and should focus on the common good of all. A.I.G. is not part of the common good.

So Mr. Greenberg, be smart and grow up. There is too much pain going on in this country to have to hear lawsuits that don’t make much sense. Be part of capitalism and learn to compete.

Alex Uzarowicz
Alex Uzarowicz has been a weekly conservative political columnist for The Knox Student for three years. He also writes for The College Conservative. Alex will graduate in June 2013 with a degree in political science, after which he will head abroad to begin his Peace Corps service.

Tags:  A.I.G. bailout Bush financial lawsuit market shares stocks tax

Bookmark and Share




Previous Post
Smith focused on 'democratizing the classroom'
Next Post
Debating columnists: A.I.G. potential lawsuit



Alex Uzarowicz
Alex Uzarowicz has been a weekly conservative political columnist for The Knox Student for three years. He also writes for The College Conservative. Alex will graduate in June 2013 with a degree in political science, after which he will head abroad to begin his Peace Corps service.




You might also like




  • Steven Allen, Esq.

    Alex,

    I don’t know if I am sad, disappointed or shocked by your lack of research before authoring your editoral, “AIG – abundant in greed.”

    Based on your comments, as follows, you clearly did not research the matter before opining as to the AIG situation:

    “A.I.G. is now mostly publicly owned. About 77 percent of A.I.G.’s assets belong to the government and come up to $186 billion. A.I.G. only owns about $14.9 billion of its shares.

    It’s pathetic that such a powerful institution still hasn’t paid back its bailout money. Companies like these should not be part of the private sector in the first place. If A.I.G. couldn’t come up with the money in the last four years since the bailout, then it doesn’t deserve more money from the government and should be completely privatized.”

    Had you spent five minutes research this matter, you would have learned that AIG has indeed repaid the government all bailout money owed, with a profit to the American taxpayers of $22B.

    Joshua Gunter prepared an editorial on the same date, 1/23/13, and on the same subject. Joshua clearly understood the current status of the AIG matter; including the fact that AIG had a fiduciary duty to consider joining the lawsuit again the government brought by Greenberg.

    If people read your editorial, without conducting their own research, they would have a distorted view of the matter.

    You owe more to your readers.

    /s/ Steven Allen

  • Alex Uzarowicz

    Dear Steve,
    I stand corrected. I misunderstood the facts and you are completely right. However, this doesn’t take away from the fact that AIG remains a greedy company. The fact that they considered to file a lawsuit against the American people (taxpayers’)is unbelievable. Thanks for the correction.



More Story
Smith focused on 'democratizing the classroom'
 was awarded Educator of the Year for her work at Macalaster College, despite having only begun her work as a professor...