Login | Register | Forgot Password?  
The Knox Student Online
Student-written, student-run, student-read since 1878. Student-programmed since 2007.

Thoughts from the Embers: Effective communication

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Read 480 times. 3 comments.

Over the past few weeks, several students have taken issue with the recent sexual assaults on campus, producing an array of responses. From posters glued to the walls to informative zines about sexual assault to an open forum arranged by two individual students, the campus has been buzzing with discussion about the issues.

The initial response to the two sexual assaults that occurred in the same January week was anonymous posters glued to the wall in Seymour, several of which were pulled down shortly after they were hung, despite the glue. Later, smaller posters were glued all over Seymour and the Quads. These posters either displayed a statement about women on campus or a cartoon suggesting that Knox was sweeping complaints about sexual assault under the rug. These posters were also hastily taken down and the glue cleaned by the custodial staff.

Gluing the posters was disrespectful. The glue didn’t make the posters any more permanent than the tape would have.

Then, similar posters were mailed to every student box on campus. While some students may have appreciated the hand-delivered poster, others did not appreciate the receiving that message in their mailbox. The posters also created extra work for the employees of the mail room.

Conversely, other students have taken a more active and respectful approach to dealing with these issues. Some students created informative zines to educate students about sexual assault. Others joined the Executive Committee and Student Life Committee last week to share their opinions about the way sexual assault is handled on campus. Finally, Trevor Sorenson and Angie Ostaszewski, two individual students, organized an open forum for students and faculty to discuss the problems and hopefully arrive at some solutions.

These events have shown that students can responsibly take initiative for the problems on campus and spark discussion focused directly on the issues. The organizers of this forum are in a better position to affect change on campus because they are working within the system and sending a clear message to the administration.

Knox students should be outraged by the recent incidences. But they should also show they are mature enough to handle this outrage constructively. Those who hung these posters had no business creating extra work for the custodial staff. Additionally, some of these posters placed unfair blame on the Greek system and incorrectly implied that all women feel the same way about sexual assault on campus and agree with the poster’s message.

On the other hand, Trevor and Angie and the other students who have found more constructive ways of channeling their outrage have provided students with education and the opportunity to speak for themselves on the issue. If there is a problem, students have the means to create a gathering or open a forum and make recommendations for the future. Students often work closely with administrators to make improvements.

Thank you to those who have represented the student body so well in handling this issue. We recommend that those who want to see change at Knox take note and follow suit.

If the Knox administration stifled public speech and discourse about tough issues, if students were not allowed to gather or make recommendations for change, if it were against the rules to challenge the administration, then posters glued to the walls would be justified. However, all of these things are allowed to happen. In fact, Knox prides itself on the level of participation in administrative decisions that it allows students to have. Therefore, there is no reason to temporarily damage Knox buildings in order to ensure that a challenging voice is heard.


Comments


9/06/2010
6:59 p.m.
 
 
vicky daza
3/04/2010
3:55 p.m.
wow for all the 'discourse' there is against polarization on campus, one would think TKS wouldn't perpetuate that by dividing the different efforts against sexual assault.
there is more than one way to go about things.

and i'm sure you all know as well as everyone else does that taped posters are easily torn down, and this is really evident by the amount of backlash against the messages on those posters, because it took the way the option for people to blindly ignore sexual assault as something that happens often on campus.
i guess the use of glue, just made it easier to create excuses to voice opposition.


and the upperclassmen know that for quite a few years now SASS and other groups have tried to create reform on campus relating to sexual assault. and for years the same argument is used, "it's disrespectful, you're over reacting, it's anti-greek." and in the end little has come of it.
i understand it makes people feel uncomfortable being reminded that rape happens quite often on campus. it should make you uncomfortable, that's the point.

 
Brian Camozzi
3/04/2010
4:13 p.m.
I bring up (again) the "discourse bell curve." When the normal methods are suppressed or rendered ineffective (i.e. through pervasive control by vested interests), more discourse occurs on the outliers. The use of the glue, unfortunate and (in my view) poorly chosen though it was, is but one symptom of a larger discourse problem. When we treat these sorts of actions as "the uncivil discourse problem" without looking at the underlying issues that encourage this type of speech over other types, we end up with draconian restrictions on some speech to match the existing social/bureaucratic suppression of other speech. It will only polarize campus further, away from the happy medium of a vigorous, participatory democracy and into two camps on either extreme of our discourse bell curve - the silent and the rebellious.

A college divided against itself (by four standard deviations, no less) cannot stand.
 
Erin Souza
4/08/2010
3:37 p.m.
I completely agree with this article.
 

 

Post a comment

Sexist, racist, homophobic, or other forms of hate speech are not allowed on theknoxstudent.com. We ask that users keep their comments on-topic. Personal attacks against anyone are not allowed. If these rules are violated the TKS staff retains the right to temporarily or permanently ban an individual's account, as well as the right to moderate discussions.

You are not currently logged in. You can login here.